This month’s Masonic education topic is harmony—not simply getting along but learning to work together even when we disagree. As your lodge prepares for its next meeting, consider what it takes to set aside personal differences, make room for other perspectives, and find common ground. This month’s reading offers a lesson from America’s founding fathers on the value of humility, compromise, and recognizing our own limits.
The presidential election of 1800 was vicious—partisan mudslinging at its worst. A campaign in which each side called the other an enemy of the Constitution ended in a 73–73 Electoral College tie between Thomas Jefferson and his running mate, Aaron Burr. The House of Representatives finally broke the tie on the 36th ballot, choosing Jefferson. Following the first-ever peaceful transfer of presidential power between rival political parties in America, all eyes were on Jefferson as he delivered his inaugural presidential address.
What followed was a striking plea for reconciliation. Jefferson tried to defuse the tensions, reminding the new country that Americans were more than their factions and, importantly, that “every difference of opinion is not a difference of principle.”
What is good for a nascent democracy is good for a Masonic lodge. Masons are charged to uphold harmony within the lodge, not to let differences of opinion fracture the vital bond between brothers. Harmony here is not an excuse to avoid difficult conversations—a call for getting along to get along. Rather, harmony represents a commitment to take a better, if not more difficult, path. Fighting is easy—or at least feels satisfying in the moment. It is much harder to set aside our egos. Opinions are, after all, formulations of ourselves—not codified or sacred truths, but the particular products of each individual.
Fourteen years before Jefferson’s address, another founding father urged the statesmen gathered on the last day of the Constitutional Convention to remember that distinction. Unable to read the speech himself, Benjamin Franklin had a colleague relay his thoughts. Franklin had misgivings about the Constitution they had forged together over the previous months. But he would ultimately sign it, believing it was the best they could do. He had a message for those who also harbored misgivings: Every man who disagreed should join him in “doubting a little of his own infallibility.”
Harmony is not the absence of difference. It is the decision to sign anyway.
Consider this: When has a difference of opinion made our lodge stronger? How can we disagree without damaging our relationships?
|